【why is it ok to objectify men to bro code】German Court Issues a Dangerous Verdict for the ECB
(Bloomberg Opinion) -- Germany’s constitutional court has issued a dangerous verdict on the European Central Bank’s original quantitative easing program. Thewhy is it ok to objectify men to bro code ECB won’t find it particularly hard to comply with the court’s demand to show that it acted proportionately in launching its bond-buying scheme. However, the judgment poses deep institutional questions about the independence of the euro zone’s central bank and the relationship between domestic and European Union law.
The near-unanimous ruling from the eight red-robed judges is doubly ironic. Since the ECB’s creation, the dominant view in Germany has been that it should be shielded from political influence, in the same way as the Bundesbank. The country also hoped that the ECB would interpret its mandate narrowly, prioritizing its objective to keep inflation “below but close to 2%” over any wider concerns. Yet the court in Karlsruhe has essentially ruled that German institutions should be doing more to monitor the central bank’s actions, calling into question its independence, and demanded that the Frankfurt institution shows that it took broader economic and fiscal considerations into account — not just inflation — when deciding to pursue QE.
The judges have asked that Germany’s government and parliament press the ECB to show that it acted proportionately in launching its original asset-purchase program, including taking into account those non-inflation concerns. Were the central bank to fail to provide this assessment within three months, Germany’s Bundesbank would have to withdraw from the bond-buying scheme.
The ECB should be able to clear this bar pretty easily. It’s obvious to any casual observer of central-banking matters that policy makers weren’t fixated solely on inflation as they launched QE at the start of 2015. There are dozens of speeches and papers in which members of the ECB’s Governing Council and officials look at areas such as income, wealth distribution and financial stability. If these points need repeating for the sake of satisfying a court in Germany, so be it.
The trouble is that in doing so the ECB would accept two dramatic institutional points that the constitutional court is asserting. The first is that the German judges have a duty to scrutinize the ECB since the European Court of Justice hasn’t done so properly. If that’s the case, then surely the courts of all member states have the right to quibble with anything the ECB has done. That would create a legal and institutional nightmare, making the central bank’s life next to impossible.
Story continues
The court’s second point is that the German parliament and government has the right to put the ECB under greater scrutiny. It’s not clear why this should be the case. The ECB is already held accountable to European citizens via the European Parliament, which holds regular hearings with Christine Lagarde, the central bank’s president. It also publishes the minutes of its decisions and governing council members regularly give speeches and interviews to explain what they’re doing. It’s not clear why Germany’s politicians and courts deserve better treatment than everyone else.
The ECB’s council will meet on Tuesday evening to discuss the decision. Investors will watch its next steps with great anxiety. In theory, it can keep buying sovereign and corporate debt under its original QE program even without the Bundesbank’s involvement. Moreover, its new pandemic-related QE scheme isn’t subject to this ruling. It can continue unfettered — at least until a new legal decision is made.
However, were the Bundesbank to stop purchasing bonds in the original QE scheme, it would raise deep doubts about the strength of the monetary union. There are also indirect questions over the future of the pandemic-related program, which doesn’t abide by a number of rules that were part of the original QE program and which the court says are “crucial” to ensure that the central bank doesn’t engage in monetary financing (the direct funding of government by a central bank). These include limiting the ECB’s purchases of a country’s bonds depending on the relative size of its economy and buying less than a third of each state’s outstanding debt.
The ECB has always managed to paper over the institutional incompleteness of the euro zone, thanks to flexible and creative thinking. However, the inevitable tensions of having a monetary union without a federal state can’t be suppressed forever. This week’s ruling shows the severe limitations of the current setup. Politicians must decide what euro zone they want — and do it quickly.
This column does not necessarily reflect the opinion of the editorial board or Bloomberg LP and its owners.
Ferdinando Giugliano writes columns on European economics for Bloomberg Opinion. He is also an economics columnist for La Repubblica and was a member of the editorial board of the Financial Times.
For more articles like this, please visit us at
bloomberg.com/opinion
Subscribe now
to stay ahead with the most trusted business news source.
©2020 Bloomberg L.P.
View comments
-
AP Top Extended Financial Headlines at 9:52 p.m. ESTGeneral Electric Rises 3%Boeing Is Set to Beat Airbus in the 2018 Order RaceIs AEW UK Long Lease REIT Plc (LON:AEWL) A Healthy REIT?Were Hedge Funds Right About Dumping Retail Value Inc. (RVI)?‘Futurama’ Drama Resolved: John DiMaggio Returns for New Season on HuluU.S. Dollar Mixed As Weak Asian Data Offset Signs of Trade ProgressDEADLINE ALERT - Bronstein, Gewirtz & Grossman, LLC Reminds Investors of Class Action Against Apogee Enterprises, Inc. (APOG) and Lead Plaintiff Deadline - January 4, 2019S.Korea's Moon tells Trump he would accept invitation to G7 summitWhy Palo Alto Networks Has Spent Over $1 Billion on Acquisitions
下一篇:Moving Average Crossover Alert: Tenable
- ·ETFs Ways to Tap the Rise in Silver Price
- ·What Kind Of Investor Owns Most Of China Primary Energy Holdings Limited (HKG:8117)?
- ·FCPA Lawyer Predicts GCs, CCOs Have Targets on Their Backs in 2019
- ·Japan's Nintendo, Line team up for new Mario mobile game
- ·JPMorgan Chase approved to process $15 billion in new PPP loans
- ·Nigeria's Kaduna refinery expected to resume by mid-April - NNPC
- ·Missouri Supreme Court suspends second talc cancer trial in weeks
- ·BRIEF-Golden Shield Holdings (Industrial) Re-Filed New Listing Application To Stock Exchange
- ·GLOBAL MARKETS-Asian shares go flat as China data disappoints
- ·Are These Bulls Right About Philip Morris International?
- ·An ETF to Consider if the U.S.-China Trade War Triggers a Black Swan Event
- ·Roku to launch subscription video channels business
- ·One Metric To Rule Them All: Ground Rents Income Fund PLC (LON:GRIO)
- ·3 Stocks Peter Lynch Would Love
- ·Why the Earnings Surprise Streak Could Continue for Stryker (SYK)
- ·Watch This 2JZ-Powered Ford Sierra Hit 175 MPH on Ice
- ·SHAREHOLDER ALERT: Pomerantz Law Firm Investigates Claims On Behalf of Investors of Peabody Energy Corporation
- ·Watch the first two minutes of 'The Walking Dead' midseason premiere
- ·U.S. Court Denies Bid to Fast Track Appeal in $1.2B Venezuela Arbitration Dispute
- ·Should You Be Impressed By Michael Hill International Limited’s (ASX:MHJ) ROE?
- ·Realogy Holdings Corp.'s (NYSE:RLGY) Intrinsic Value Is Potentially 88% Above Its Share Price
- ·Malaysian palm producer FGV appoints new chief financial officer
- ·EOS Climbs 10% In Bullish Trade
- ·BRIEF-Tianjin Capital Environmental Protection Wins Bid For Sewage Treatment PPP Project
- ·Is KB Financial Group, Inc. (KB) A Good Stock To Buy?
- ·Are These Bulls Right About Philip Morris International?
- ·Read This Before Selling Altura Mining Limited (ASX:AJM) Shares
- ·See which colours dominated your Instagram posts in 2018
- ·Twin Disc: Fiscal 2Q Earnings Snapshot
- ·FOREX-Yen soars as growth concerns dampen appetite
- ·What's in Store for Ambarella (AMBA) This Earnings Season?
- ·Trump says China could have hacked Democratic emails
- ·Pacific Ridge Receives $1.2 Million Payment from BMC
- ·Online Shopping & Travel Mall MyReviewsNow Promotes Affiliate Merchant Camping World's '8th Annual Outdoor & RV Expo' to Its Members and Shoppers
- ·CRON INVESTOR FILING DEADLINE: Bernstein Liebhard LLP Reminds Investors of a Filing Deadline in a Securities Class Action Against Cronos Group Inc.
- ·Activision Blizzard plans to terminate CFO Neumann